At the default inputs, Interactive Brokers (IMPACT tools) has the lowest estimated 10-year fee drag at $623. Compare advisory fees and fund costs across five sustainable investing platforms, then inspect the ETFs inside each portfolio. Estimates use a constant 7% annual return and are not a forecast.
Key Model Assumptions & Benchmark Data
- Betterment LLC — Form ADV Part 2 (Reviewed 2026-11-09):$5 per month, or 0.25% a year at $24,000+ or with a $200 monthly recurring deposit
- Wealthfront Advisers LLC — Form CRS (Reviewed 2026-11-09):0.25% annual wrap fee and $500 minimum
- Carbon Collective Investing, LLC — Wrap Fee Programs Brochure (Reviewed 2026-11-09):1.00% up to $5,000 and 0.25% above $5,000
- M1 Finance LLC (Reviewed 2026-11-09):$3 monthly platform fee, waived with $10,000 in M1 assets or an active M1 Personal Loan
- Interactive Brokers LLC (Reviewed 2026-11-09):$0 commissions on U.S. stocks and ETFs for U.S. IBKR Lite clients placing manual orders, with Fixed Pricing on recurring investment instructions; no account minimum
Interactive Model & Inputs
Adjust variables below to instantly compute real-time projections and amortization.
Calculation Results & Payback Projections
Ranked by estimated 10-year fee drag. The cheapest option leaves out automation and tax-loss harvesting, which you would handle yourself. Fees checked November 2026 against published schedules.
Some links below are affiliate links, and we may earn a commission if you sign up. Commissions do not affect the numbers or the ranking.
Interactive Brokers (IMPACT tools)
A brokerage account with values tools that score holdings against 13 values and flag practices to avoid. Shown with the same example basket as M1, which you would buy and rebalance yourself.
Advisory fee: No advisory fee. $0 commissions on U.S. stocks and ETFs for IBKR Lite clients placing orders manually; recurring investment instructions pay Fixed Pricing commissions.
- Year-1 total cost
- $19.06
- $0 advisory + $19 funds
- All-in rate, year 1
- 0.21%
- 0.205% fund cost included
- 10-year fee drag
- $623
- at 7% gross, compounded monthly
- Green bonds: 20%
- Tax-loss harvesting: Not automated.
Inspect 4 holdings and sources
Example basket chosen by The Impact Investor. It is not a model portfolio from Interactive Brokers. Portfolio data as of 2026-11-09. Weighted cost of the example basket below.
| Ticker | Fund | Asset class | Weight | Fund ER |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SPYX | State Street SPDR S&P 500 Fossil Fuel Reserves Free ETF | U.S. large-cap stocks | 55% | 0.20% |
| EFAX | State Street SPDR MSCI EAFE Fossil Fuel Reserves Free ETF | International developed stocks | 20% | 0.20% |
| BGRN | iShares USD Green Bond ETF | Global green bonds | 20% | 0.20% |
| EEMX | State Street SPDR MSCI Emerging Markets Fossil Fuel Reserves Free ETF | Emerging market stocks | 5% | 0.30% |
- IBKR stock and ETF commissions (checked 2026-11-09)
- IBKR IMPACT overview (checked 2026-11-09)
- IBKR Impact Dashboard guide (checked 2026-11-09)
- State Street product lineup (checked 2026-11-09)
M1 custom Pie
No built-in fossil-free portfolio. You choose every fund in a Pie, so the screen is only as strict as what you build. New deposits are directed toward your target weights automatically.
Advisory fee: $3 a month, waived with $10,000+ in M1 assets or an active M1 Personal Loan
- Year-1 total cost
- $49.03
- $30 advisory + $19 funds
- All-in rate, year 1
- 0.53%
- 0.205% fund cost included
- 10-year fee drag
- $680
- at 7% gross, compounded monthly
Fee alert: The $3 monthly platform fee applies until your M1 assets reach $10,000 at least one day in the billing cycle.
- Green bonds: 20%
- Tax-loss harvesting: Not automated.
Inspect 4 holdings and sources
Example basket chosen by The Impact Investor. It is not a model portfolio from M1. Portfolio data as of 2026-11-09. Weighted cost of the example basket below.
| Ticker | Fund | Asset class | Weight | Fund ER |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SPYX | State Street SPDR S&P 500 Fossil Fuel Reserves Free ETF | U.S. large-cap stocks | 55% | 0.20% |
| EFAX | State Street SPDR MSCI EAFE Fossil Fuel Reserves Free ETF | International developed stocks | 20% | 0.20% |
| BGRN | iShares USD Green Bond ETF | Global green bonds | 20% | 0.20% |
| EEMX | State Street SPDR MSCI Emerging Markets Fossil Fuel Reserves Free ETF | Emerging market stocks | 5% | 0.30% |
- M1 first deposit minimums (checked 2026-11-09)
- M1 platform fee (checked 2026-11-09)
- M1 first deposit minimums (checked 2026-11-09)
- State Street product lineup (checked 2026-11-09)
Wealthfront Socially Responsible
ESG tilt, not fossil-free. The iShares ESG Aware funds exclude tobacco, controversial weapons, civilian firearms, thermal coal and oil sands, but keep other energy companies. The U.S. fund's index was 3.57% energy on September 30, 2026.
Advisory fee: 0.25% a year
- Year-1 total cost
- $39.94
- $23 advisory + $17 funds
- All-in rate, year 1
- 0.43%
- 0.18% fund cost included
- 10-year fee drag
- $1,295
- at 7% gross, compounded monthly
- Green bonds: 0%
- Tax-loss harvesting: Included for taxable accounts, on every ETF in the portfolio.
Inspect 5 holdings and sources
Wealthfront's example at risk level 8.0 of 10 and a medium tax level. Your mix depends on your risk level, tax level and account type. Portfolio data as of 2026-11-09. High end of Wealthfront's published 0.09% to 0.18% weighted range.
| Ticker | Fund | Asset class | Weight | Fund ER |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ESGU | iShares ESG Aware MSCI USA ETF | U.S. stocks | 60% | 0.15% |
| ESGD | iShares ESG Aware MSCI EAFE ETF | Foreign developed stocks | 12% | 0.20% |
| SUSC | iShares ESG Aware USD Corporate Bond ETF | Corporate bonds | 11% | 0.18% |
| ESGE | iShares ESG Aware MSCI EM ETF | Emerging market stocks | 11% | 0.25% |
| SCHP | Schwab U.S. TIPS ETF | TIPS | 6% | 0.03% |
- Wealthfront Socially Responsible portfolio (checked 2026-11-09)
- Wealthfront SRI fund costs (checked 2026-11-09)
- Wealthfront Form CRS (checked 2026-11-09)
- MSCI Extended ESG Focus methodology (checked 2026-11-09)
- MSCI USA Extended ESG Focus factsheet (checked 2026-11-09)
Betterment Climate Impact
Partial fossil-fuel exclusion. About 45% of the 90/10 model sits in CRBN, which tilts away from carbon emitters but is not fossil-free. SPYX, EFAX and EEMX exclude owners of fossil fuel reserves.
Advisory fee: $5 a month, or 0.25% a year at $24,000+ or with $200+ a month in recurring deposits, with lower rates on balances above $1 million
- Year-1 total cost
- $77.61
- $60 advisory + $18 funds
- All-in rate, year 1
- 0.84%
- 0.19% fund cost included
- 10-year fee drag
- $1,528
- at 7% gross, compounded monthly
Fee alert: The $5 monthly fee applies below $24,000 unless your household has $200+ a month in recurring deposits.
- Green bonds: 8.4%
- Tax-loss harvesting: Included for taxable accounts. In this portfolio, only the fossil-fuel-reserve-free ETFs are eligible.
Inspect 8 holdings and sources
Target weights for the 90% stock, 10% bond model. Taxable accounts may also hold alternate tickers, and actual holdings vary. Portfolio data as of 2026-11-08. High end of Betterment's published 0.13% to 0.19% range for Climate Impact, as of May 31, 2026.
| Ticker | Fund | Asset class | Weight | Fund ER |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CRBN | iShares Low Carbon Optimized MSCI ACWI ETF | Global low-carbon stocks | 45% | 0.20% |
| SPYX | State Street SPDR S&P 500 Fossil Fuel Reserves Free ETF | U.S. large-cap stocks | 18.8% | 0.20% |
| EFAX | State Street SPDR MSCI EAFE Fossil Fuel Reserves Free ETF | International developed stocks | 12.3% | 0.20% |
| BGRN | iShares USD Green Bond ETF | Global green bonds | 8.4% | 0.20% |
| VOTE | TCW Transform 500 ETF | U.S. shareholder engagement stocks | 5.4% | 0.05% |
| EEMX | State Street SPDR MSCI Emerging Markets Fossil Fuel Reserves Free ETF | Emerging market stocks | 4.3% | 0.30% |
| ESML | iShares ESG Aware MSCI USA Small-Cap ETF | U.S. small-cap stocks | 4.2% | 0.17% |
| VWOB | Vanguard Emerging Markets Government Bond ETF | Emerging market bonds | 1.2% | 0.15% |
- Betterment Form ADV Part 2 (checked 2026-11-09)
- Betterment pricing (checked 2026-11-09)
- Betterment fee disclosure (checked 2026-11-09)
- Betterment SRI fund fees (checked 2026-11-09)
- Betterment Climate Impact holdings (checked 2026-11-09)
- Betterment SRI portfolios disclosure (checked 2026-11-09)
Carbon Collective ClimateSmart Core
Avoids fossil fuel producers and overweights climate solutions, including its own CCSO stock fund and CCSB green bond fund. It still holds materials and industrial companies, such as steelmakers inside CCSO.
Advisory fee: 1.00% on the first $5,000 and 0.25% above it
- Year-1 total cost
- $97.70
- $61 advisory + $37 funds
- All-in rate, year 1
- 1.05%
- 0.4% fund cost included
- 10-year fee drag
- $2,461
- at 7% gross, compounded monthly
Fee alert: The 1.00% tier on the first $5,000 costs up to $50 a year, so small balances carry a higher effective rate.
- Green bonds: 5.85%
- Tax-loss harvesting: Optional for taxable accounts, at an extra 0.10% a year.
Inspect 18 holdings and sources
Core portfolio as published by Carbon Collective. A dash means we could not confirm that fund's expense ratio. Portfolio data as of 2025-05-15. Carbon Collective says most portfolios come in around 0.40%.
| Ticker | Fund | Asset class | Weight | Fund ER |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| IXN | iShares Global Tech ETF | Technology | 24.84% | — |
| CCSO | Carbon Collective Climate Solutions U.S. Equity ETF | Climate solutions | 16.3% | 0.35% |
| IXJ | iShares Global Healthcare ETF | Healthcare | 10.11% | 0.38% |
| IXP | iShares Global Comm Services ETF | Telecommunications | 7.94% | — |
| FDIS | Fidelity MSCI Consumer Discretionary Index ETF | Consumer discretionary | 6.92% | — |
| CCSB | Carbon Collective Short Duration Green Bond ETF | Green bonds | 5.85% | 0.50% |
| EUFN | iShares MSCI Europe Financials ETF | Financials | 5.46% | — |
| Custom | Carbon Collective consumer staples sleeve | Consumer staples | 5.46% | — |
| KRE | State Street SPDR S&P Regional Banking ETF | Financials | 2.73% | — |
| KIE | State Street SPDR S&P Insurance ETF | Financials | 2.73% | — |
| KCE | State Street SPDR S&P Capital Markets ETF | Financials | 2.73% | — |
| VGSR | Vert Global Sustainable Real Estate ETF | Real estate | 2.48% | — |
| CHIQ | Global X MSCI China Consumer Discretionary ETF | Consumer discretionary | 2.31% | 0.65% |
| STIP | iShares 0-5 Year TIPS Bond ETF | TIPS | 1.35% | — |
| Cash | Cash | Cash | 1% | — |
| BWX | SPDR Bloomberg International Treasury Bond ETF | Non-U.S. government bonds | 0.9% | — |
| SPTL | SPDR Portfolio Long Term Treasury ETF | U.S. long-term Treasuries | 0.45% | — |
| SCHR | Schwab Intermediate-Term U.S. Treasury ETF | U.S. intermediate Treasuries | 0.45% | — |
- Carbon Collective pricing (checked 2026-11-09)
- Carbon Collective individuals overview (checked 2026-11-09)
- Carbon Collective Wrap Fee Brochure (checked 2026-11-09)
- ClimateSmart portfolio breakdown (checked 2026-11-09)
- CCSO annual shareholder report (checked 2026-11-09)
Where Older ESG Platforms Went
Automated accounts transferred to Betterment on April 10, 2025, unless clients opted out. Ellevest now offers wealth management from $500,000. Source
The consumer accounts moved to the GreenFi brand on April 22, 2025, and the Redwood Fund took the GreenFi name the day before. Source
The service now operates as Empower Personal Strategy, with a $100,000 minimum and fees starting at 0.89%. Source
J.P. Morgan agreed to buy the values-based investing platform in 2021. Source
Swell ended operations on August 30, 2019, citing a lack of scale. Source
How the ESG Robo-Advisor Fee Model Works
A sustainable portfolio has two layers of cost: what the platform charges and what the funds inside it charge. This calculator adds both for five platforms, using each provider’s published fee schedule.
Your balance grows month by month at a constant 7% gross annual return, compounded monthly at 7%/12. Each month the model adds your deposit, then subtracts that month’s advisory fee and fund cost. Fee thresholds are checked every month, so a flat fee stops once a growing account reaches its waiver level.
Fund cost uses the high end of each provider’s published range, so costs are not understated. M1 and Interactive Brokers have no portfolio of their own to measure, so both use one example basket that we chose and labeled as an example. This tool is for education and is not investment advice. Returns are hypothetical, and actual results will differ.
Monthly Fee Drag Simulation
Balance(m) = Balance(m-1) × (1 + 7%/12) + Deposit - Advisory Fee(m) - Balance × Fund Cost/12; Drag = No-Fee Balance(120) - Balance(120)The advisory fee is recalculated each month from the current balance and recurring deposit. The year-one rate divides the advisory fees and fund costs from the first 12 modeled months by the average balance over those months.
Worked example: understand your inputs
At $8,000 with $150 a month, Interactive Brokers (IMPACT tools) has the lowest estimated 10-year fee drag at $623. With no fees at all, the same deposits would reach $42,040.
| Input | Example value | What to enter |
|---|---|---|
| Starting Balance | 8000 | The amount you plan to keep invested in this portfolio, in dollars. |
| Monthly Deposit | 150 | Recurring deposit added each month just before that month's fees are charged, in dollars. |
| Screen Filter | all | Limits the ranking to one screening approach. |
How to interpret the result
Fee drag is the balance you give up over ten years, including the growth those fees would have earned. Compare it with what each platform does for you, because the cheapest option leaves automation and tax-loss harvesting to you.
What this estimate leaves out
Markets do not earn a constant 7% a year. The model excludes taxes, tax-loss harvesting benefits, trading spreads and account-transfer fees. Fee waivers are tested only against the balance and deposit you enter, so cash or other eligible accounts at Betterment or M1, or an active M1 Personal Loan, could remove a flat fee shown here. Carbon Collective's overview page mentions a $1 monthly account maintenance fee that its pricing page and November 2026 wrap fee brochure do not list, so that fee is not modeled. Interactive Brokers figures assume manual, commission-free IBKR Lite orders, because recurring investment instructions pay Fixed Pricing commissions. M1 figures charge the flat fee from the first month, but M1 says logins created after February 15, 2024 begin billing 90 days after sign-up, so a new account can pay up to $9 less in its first year. Portfolio mixes vary by risk level, and Carbon Collective publishes a blended fund cost rather than a figure for each investor.
What to Check Beyond the Fee
Flat fees on small balances
A $3 or $5 monthly fee can cost more than a percentage fee until the account grows or the waiver applies.
What the screen removes
ESG tilts, low-carbon funds and fossil-fuel exclusions are different things. Open the holdings to see which one you are buying.
Services included
Automated rebalancing and tax-loss harvesting have value in taxable accounts, and a self-directed account leaves that work to you.
How current the data is
Each portfolio shows its as-of date and sources. Check the provider’s current disclosures before you open an account.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Betterment and Wealthfront socially responsible portfolios fossil-fuel free?
No. Wealthfront’s portfolio uses iShares ESG Aware funds that exclude thermal coal and oil sands but keep other energy companies. Betterment’s Climate Impact portfolio combines fossil-fuel-reserve-free funds with CRBN, a low-carbon fund that is not fossil-free.
How much does Betterment charge on a small balance?
Betterment charges $5 a month below $24,000 unless your household has at least $200 a month in recurring deposits. At $24,000 or more, or with that deposit, the fee is 0.25% a year. On a $5,000 balance, $60 a year is 1.20% before fund costs.
Why does the model use the high end of each fund cost range?
Providers publish a range because fund costs change with your stock and bond mix. Using the high end keeps the comparison from understating what a more stock-heavy investor would pay.
Why does a self-directed account rank cheapest?
It has little or no platform fee, so its cost is mostly the funds. That ranking leaves out the automation, rebalancing and tax-loss harvesting that a robo-advisor provides.
What happened to Ellevest's automated investing?
Ellevest stopped offering automated investing, and qualifying accounts transferred to Betterment on April 10, 2025, unless clients opted out. Ellevest continues to offer wealth management from $500,000.
Authoritative Benchmark Sources & Active Incentives
Digital wrap fee schedule (Betterment LLC — Form ADV Part 2)
$5 per month, or 0.25% a year at $24,000+ or with a $200 monthly recurring deposit
Automated Investing Account wrap fee (Wealthfront Advisers LLC — Form CRS)
0.25% annual wrap fee and $500 minimum
CCI Personal fee schedule (Carbon Collective Investing, LLC — Wrap Fee Programs Brochure)
1.00% up to $5,000 and 0.25% above $5,000
Platform fee disclosure (M1 Finance LLC)
$3 monthly platform fee, waived with $10,000 in M1 assets or an active M1 Personal Loan
IMPACT overview (Interactive Brokers LLC)
$0 commissions on U.S. stocks and ETFs for U.S. IBKR Lite clients placing manual orders, with Fixed Pricing on recurring investment instructions; no account minimum
Related Financial & Clean Energy Calculators
Continue modeling your sustainable investments with companion quantitative tools.
ESG Investment Growth Calculator
Project the compound future value of ESG investments versus traditional index benchmarks over 5 to 40 years.
Portfolio Carbon Footprint Calculator
Explore illustrative portfolio emissions in tonnes CO2e using investment value and strategy assumptions. See the method, example and limitations.
Green Mortgage Calculator
Compare energy-efficient green mortgage interest rate discounts against standard conventional mortgages.